Hedge fund cornering the cocoa market

18 Jul 2010

Apart from the usual options and futures, Euronext LIFFE is also happy to accommodate trading in commodities. It turns out a certain Anthony Ward (50) bought all the cocoa in Europe. Last Friday, his hedge fund Armajaro opted for physical delivery with the expiring July futures. For as little as EUR 800 million you can have all the cocoa stored in warehouses in Amsterdam and in several minor cities such as Antwerp, Felixstowe, Hamburg and Rotterdam. I’m no expert on cocoa beans, or to be specific how long you can preserve the quality of the beans, but Ward sure knows what he’s doing. The ex-Chairman of European Cocoa Association isn’t doing this for the first time in his life.

Press is reporting the “biggest cocoa trade in fourteen years”, but it’s not that special. Back 2002 the same cacao king Anthony Ward bought 202.000 tons, just a little less compared to the current 241.000. At the time his purchase represented 5% of the world market. He made 40 million in 2002 on the trade. Three years ago Ward was quoted as the chocolate guru : “The world’s not going to run out of cocoa, but they’ll have to pay more to get the right beans”. Most press reports refer to the biggest cocoa trade in fourteen years, but haven’t done any more research. The large cocoa trade in 1996 was done by the firm Phibro, amounting 300.000 tons. In charge of the cocoa desk at the time at Phibro, was nobody else than the same Anthony Ward. Phibro lost money on this cocoa trade by the way, and was forced to unwind their positions.

Bad luck for the cacao farmers, as they have already sold their stock and don’t benefit from the price raise. Fairtrade Organizations are eager to use the public tide against financial markets for their cause. There’s good news anyway for us consumers. There’s not much cocoa in the candy bars. The Tony’s Chocolonely slave-free chocolate bars will witness a steady price level.

13 Responses to Hedge fund cornering the cocoa market

Avatar

Anonymous

July 19th, 2010 at 12:14 am

first yawn. next article please

Avatar

Chocali

July 19th, 2010 at 9:32 am

Chocali bingan anyone?

Avatar

Anonymous

July 19th, 2010 at 6:37 pm

Sinterklaas wordt duur dit jaar…

Avatar

Anonymous

July 19th, 2010 at 7:50 pm

Nice article ! pls ignore the first post on the top ..

Avatar

Beth Mahoney

July 19th, 2010 at 9:29 pm

I always looked at Gold and Silver, didn’t know the Cocoa market very well. Interesting story..

Avatar

afs

July 20th, 2010 at 7:30 am

(yday) Hedge Funds Blamed For Rising Cocoa, Coffee, Bread Prices – Anti-poverty campaigners have called upon the U.K. financial
regulator to clamp down on speculative trading that leads to food price inflation and threatens both low-income people in Britain and farmers
in developing countries. The World Development Movement, an anti-poverty campaigning group, said Monday in its latest report that hedge
funds and banks were behind the latest cocoa price surge, which caused prices to rise by more than 150% over 18 months to a 33-year
high. “Although poor harvests acted as the initial trigger for price rises in cocoa, the finger is being pointed at hedge funds and big
investment banks like Goldman Sachs for making the situation much worse by speculating on food,” it said. The recent price rise could force
some chocolate makers to raise prices and in some cases use less cocoa, it added. The report added that Goldman made significant profits
by speculating on food. A Goldman Sachs spokesperson said in an email that the report is “horribly misinformed” on a number of fronts,
adding that the overwhelming majority of its activities in commodity markets is on behalf of clients and that the profit estimates of $1 billion in
the report were “ludicrously overstated.” (WSJ)

Avatar

Anonymous

July 20th, 2010 at 9:47 am

haha .. people looking for scapegoat as usual .. those who make or more importantly might have made profit are deemed as evil .. we would go back to being socialist if they could have it their way ..

Avatar

Anonymous

July 20th, 2010 at 1:24 pm

There should be a law banning people from selling all their cocoa to people that want to buy it!!!

Avatar

sjaak

July 23rd, 2010 at 5:50 pm

Maybe only ban selling to women so that they won’t get fat

Avatar

Jacob

August 27th, 2010 at 1:21 pm

Cocoa’s Drop Pressures a Big Wager
-
Anthony Ward’s huge cocoa bet could be melting away.
Mr. Ward’s Armajaro Holdings Ltd. shook up the commodities market in July by buying a $1 billion cache of cocoa, enough to make 15 billion Hershey’s milk-chocolate bars. But since Mr. Ward made his audacious bet, cocoa prices have dropped 26%.

Two hedge funds run by Armajaro, including its CC+ Fund, which focuses on cocoa and coffee, lost about 6% of their value during the first two weeks of August, according to investors who have viewed the returns. And since then, prices have continued to decline, suggesting Mr. Ward could be coming under more pressure.

It isn’t certain the drop in cocoa is to blame for the recent losses. And some analysts say the recent decline in prices may be short-lived. An Armajaro spokesman declined to comment.

The funds remained up about 12% on the year through the middle of August, the investors say.

Mr. Ward, a 50-year-old trader, has gained a level of prominence in the commodities markets, having made big bets on cocoa at least twice before, in 1996 and in 2002.
{http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704913704575454011349605640.html}

Avatar

Research Mindz

September 5th, 2010 at 6:49 am

Cocoa prices are affected by the supply concerns from Ivory Coast, the largest country that produces Cocoa. Moreover recent bulk deal had a limited impact on the global Cocoa prices. Here’s an interesting reesearch report: http://www.researchmindz.com/Cocoa.pdf

Avatar

Jacob

December 17th, 2010 at 6:37 am

It’s a wrap: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-16/armajaro-s-cocoa-hedge-fund-liquidates-position-ft-reports.html

Armajaro Holdings Ltd., a London- based commodities hedge fund, closed a bullish position in cocoa that led to a surge in prices this year, the Financial Times reported, without saying where it got the information.

Avatar

anonymous

December 18th, 2010 at 5:26 pm

it wud be interesting reads when glencore n party get listed .. they are such huge centres of profitability ..

' '
  • anonymous: Considering how little money TOM makes and how much they put in, they were probably happy for someon [...]
  • anonymous: They were the guys who conceived TOM. IMC and ABN piggy backed later. Not sure how VC works in NL, b [...]
  • anonymous: how is optiver the real gainer - through lowering of exchange cost and increase in the value of its [...]
  • anonymous: so if bnp gets direct savings from tom, why is Edwin van der Schoot wondering about bnp screwing up [...]
  • anonymous: Isnt optiver the real gainer with gain in TOM ? [...]
  • anonymous: In America there are option exchanges who charge a fee to execute a transaction and there are others [...]
  • anonymous: I don't get it. Suppose the market is 4.10 - 4.20 on both Euronext and TOM. Suddenly someone wan [...]
  • anonymous: @11:25 BNP itself. Euronext charges 40 cent per option contract, TOM only 20 cent. [...]
  • anonymous: so if bnp links upto tom, who get's the benefit of low costs, bnp? or there is another broker betwee [...]
  • Edwin van der Schoot: Strange: so BNP Paribas agrees to take a share in Euronext, just like ABN Amro, and than screws its [...]

Archive